Unthinkable: The Susan Smith Story (2024)
Hear from the prosecutors who handled Susan Smith's case and why authorities doubted her story from the beginning. The boys' father, David Smith, talks about why he believes 30 years in prison isn't long enough for Susan and what he's prepared to tell a SC Board of Pardons and Paroles to keep her behind bars.
Directors: Jennifer Emert, Matthew Yates.
![]() |
Susan Smith as Self |
![]() |
Harold Thompson as Self |
![]() |
Tommy Pope as Self |
![]() |
Alfred Rowe as Self |
![]() |
Jeff Bailey as Self |
![]() |
David Smith as Self |
![]() |
Jennifer Emert as Self |
![]() |
Kevin Brackett as Self |
![]() |
Tiffany Moss Smith as Self |
![]() |
Mike Lancaster as Self |
![]() |
Kelly Sease as Self |
![]() |
Tonya Brumagin as Self |
| Directing | Jennifer Emert | Director |
| Directing | Matthew Yates | Director |
| Camera | Derek Bryant | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Cody King | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Matthew Yates | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Matthew Yates | Drone Cinematographer |
| Camera | Steve Wilder | Drone Cinematographer |
| Editing | Matthew Yates | Editor |
| Production | Jennifer Emert | Executive Producer |
| Production | Derek Bryant | Executive Producer |
| Production | Matthew Yates | Executive Producer |